I used this book with my 9 year old struggling reader. We got through the entire book (231 lessons) in 10 weeks. This book would likely take 2 years to get through with a young student/new reader. Used as a remedial program you can work through as slow or as fast as you need.
Pros:
- Reasonably priced (especially if you use it over and over)
- Teaches phonics systematically
- There is no grade level, therefore older kids do not feel like they are "behind"
- Scripted (tells you exactly what to say and do)
- Doesn't require any prep work (open and go)
- Non-consumable
- May be boring or overwhelming with both parent and student text on one page and no pictures
- Doesn't go in depth into how to apply phonics rules when reading outside of this book
- A few times I found that sounds were taught differently than we say them (this is a dialect issue I'm sure-we are from California/Arizona)
- The "rules" associated with some words/phonograms aren't always explicitly explained-for example, it may say something like, "These words come from the French language so they have this sound..." and basically the student needs to memorize those words have that sound versus being able to apply the rule
If you'd like to purchase this book yourself, I'd appreciate it if you'd use my affiliate link (which gives me a portion of the purchase price in Amazon credit). Thank you!
No comments:
Post a Comment